Creative Writing Crash Course – Lesson II: Exploring Genres & Story Types

Why Genre & Story Type Matter

Every story fits into a genre, whether it's filled with magic, unraveling mysteries, or exploring the human condition. Understanding genre helps writers create stronger narratives, meet reader expectations, and refine their unique voice in storytelling.

But genre is only part of the equation—stories also follow archetypal structures that have existed for centuries. Knowing these patterns can help you shape your ideas into compelling narratives while also finding ways to twist and subvert expectations.

Many aspiring writers struggle to choose a genre or worry about being confined to one. The truth is, genre is a tool, not a restriction. It provides a framework but doesn’t dictate the creativity within it. A strong grasp of genre allows you to understand the kind of stories you want to tell and how to tell them in a way that resonates with readers.

Choosing a genre can also help establish your writing identity. Readers come to expect certain themes and tones from an author’s work, and while it’s completely fine to experiment, having a strong genre foundation can create a sense of familiarity and anticipation in your audience. Even multi-genre authors often have signature elements that tie their works together.

In this lesson, we’ll break down major fiction genres, classic story structures, and how to blend and break the rules of storytelling. By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of where your writing fits—and how to make it stand out.

Overview of Major Fiction Genres, Story Structure & Reader Expectations

Genre choice impacts not only the themes and tone of a story but also its structure and pacing. Different genres have different expectations for how a story unfolds, how tension is built, and how conflicts are resolved. Understanding these structural differences can help you craft a more engaging narrative that meets reader expectations while allowing room for creativity.

How Genre Affects Story Structure

• Fantasy & Science Fiction – Often follows an epic journey structure with a hero facing trials, learning new skills, and ultimately confronting a major conflict. These stories tend to have detailed worldbuilding and may incorporate multi-book arcs.

• Mystery & Thriller – Typically structured around discovery and revelation, with key plot points leading to a climax where the mystery is solved. Twists and red herrings are essential.

• Romance – Follows a relationship-driven arc, often including a meet-cute, growing attraction, a moment of crisis, and a satisfying resolution (usually a happy ending).

• Horror – Built on escalating tension and fear, often using a slow build to an intense climax, with dread lingering throughout the story.

• Comedy – Often has a looser, more episodic structure, with humor driving the pacing and character interactions.

• Historical Fiction & Literary Fiction – Focused on character exploration and thematic depth, often allowing for non-linear storytelling or multiple perspectives.

How Genre Shapes Reader Expectations

Readers come into a book with certain expectations based on genre. If you’re writing in a genre, it’s helpful to understand what readers anticipate—and where you have room to surprise them.

• Fantasy Readers Expect: Rich worldbuilding, magic systems, and hero’s journeys.

• Mystery Readers Expect: Puzzles to solve, clues, and a logical resolution.

• Romance Readers Expect: Emotional development, romantic tension, and a satisfying ending.

• Thriller Readers Expect: Fast pacing, suspense, and life-or-death stakes.

• Horror Readers Expect: A sense of unease, supernatural or psychological elements, and a chilling resolution.

• Science Fiction Readers Expect: Thought-provoking speculation, futuristic technology, and exploration of “what if” scenarios.

By understanding these expectations, you can satisfy readers while still subverting tropes to keep your story fresh and engaging.

Mini Exercise: Pick a genre that interests you and brainstorm a story premise that fits its typical structure. What elements will you include to meet reader expectations? How will you add your unique twist?

There are countless subgenres, but most stories fall into a core genre that shapes the mood, themes, and style of storytelling.

Below are some of the most common genres in fiction, along with key elements that define them and reader expectations:

Fantasy – Magic, myth, and otherworldly settings. (Examples: The Lord of the Rings, The Name of the Wind)

• Readers expect mythology, supernatural forces, and immersive worldbuilding.

• High fantasy often includes epic adventures, while low fantasy integrates magic into everyday life.

• Subgenres include dark fantasy, portal fantasy, and fairytale retellings.

Science Fiction – Technology, space, futuristic speculation. (Examples: Dune, The Left Hand of Darkness)

• Readers look for scientific or technological elements and how they impact society.

• Hard sci-fi focuses on realistic scientific principles, while soft sci-fi is more speculative.

• Subgenres include cyberpunk, space opera, and dystopian fiction.

Horror – Fear, suspense, and the unknown. (Examples: The Haunting of Hill House, Mexican Gothic)

• Readers expect psychological tension, supernatural elements, or deeply unsettling themes.

• Horror can be atmospheric, psychological, or rely on monsters and supernatural threats.

• Subgenres include cosmic horror, body horror, and folk horror.

Romance – Love stories and emotional arcs. (Examples: Pride and Prejudice, The Love Hypothesis)

• Requires emotional depth and romantic tension.

• Readers expect a happy or hopeful ending—otherwise, it’s a tragedy or drama.

• Subgenres include historical romance, paranormal romance, and contemporary romance.

Mystery & Thriller – Crime-solving, suspense, and secrets. (Examples: The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, Gone Girl)

• Mystery requires clear setups, clues, red herrings, and a resolution.

• Thrillers emphasize high stakes, action, and fast pacing.

• Subgenres include cozy mysteries, legal thrillers, and noir fiction.

Historical Fiction – Real-world settings with historical accuracy (The Nightingale, Pachinko)

• Readers expect well-researched settings, events, and cultural depth.

• Often blends fiction with real historical figures or events.

• Subgenres include alternate history, biographical fiction, and historical fantasy.

Comedy – Humor-driven narratives. (Good Omens, The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy)

• Can range from satire to absurdist humor.

• Often paired with other genres (romantic comedy, fantasy comedy, etc.).

• Subgenres include dark comedy, slapstick, and farce.

Literary Fiction – Deep themes, character exploration, and prose-driven. (The Goldfinch, Beloved)

• Prioritizes character development and thematic depth.

• Often defies traditional genre conventions.

• Subgenres include experimental fiction, philosophical fiction, and stream-of-consciousness narratives.

Mini Exercise: Look at your favorite book in a genre you want to write. Identify one expectation it follows and one way it subverts expectations.

High vs. Low Genre Fiction: All Stories Matter

Writers sometimes feel pressured to write “serious” literary fiction when they love genre fiction. The truth? All storytelling has value.

• High Genre Fiction: Often literary, experimental, or theme-driven (The Goldfinch, Beloved). 

• Low Genre Fiction: Popular fiction designed for broad appeal (The Hunger Games, The Da Vinci Code).

Key Takeaway: Every genre has depth and meaning. What matters is how well a story is told.

Genre-Blending & Subverting Expectations

Some examples of genre-blending include:

• Sci-Fi Fantasy → (Star Wars—a space opera with fantasy elements).

• Horror Comedy → (Shaun of the Dead—blending zombie horror with satire).

• Romantic Fantasy → (The Night Circus—a slow-burn romance in a magical setting).

Mini Exercise: Take two opposite genres and brainstorm a story premise that blends them.

FAQ: Common Genre Myths & Concerns

There are many misconceptions about genre writing that can discourage new writers or make them feel boxed in. Here are some of the most common myths and concerns—debunked.

Myth #1: You Have to Stick to One Genre Forever

Reality: Many successful writers experiment with different genres. While branding yourself within a specific genre can help build an audience, it doesn’t mean you’re locked in forever. Some authors use different pen names for different genres, while others seamlessly transition between them over time.

Myth #2: Literary Fiction is More Meaningful than Genre Fiction

Reality: Every genre has the potential for depth, complexity, and artistic merit. Genre fiction can explore profound themes, challenge societal norms, and offer rich, multi-layered narratives. The idea that only literary fiction is “serious” or “worthy” is outdated.

Myth #3: Genre Fiction is Formulaic and Predictable

Reality: While genres have conventions and reader expectations, that doesn’t mean every story is the same. It’s up to the writer to bring fresh perspectives, unique twists, and compelling storytelling to make their work stand out.

Myth #4: You Have to Be an Expert in a Genre Before Writing It

Reality: While familiarity with a genre helps, you don’t need to be an expert to start writing. Reading widely in your chosen genre can teach you the conventions, but experimentation and practice are the best ways to learn.

Myth #5: Genre Writing is Easier Than Literary Writing

Reality: Writing well in any genre requires skill, creativity, and effort. Whether crafting an intricate mystery, an epic fantasy, or a gripping romance, all genres demand thoughtful storytelling, worldbuilding, and character development.

Myth #6: Certain Genres Aren’t “Real” Writing

Reality: Some people dismiss genres like romance, horror, and fantasy as “lesser” forms of writing (the one about fantasy especially boils my blood). The truth is, these genres have rich histories, dedicated readerships, and incredible depth. Every genre is valid and valuable.

Myth #7: You Should Write to Market Instead of Passion

Reality: Writing to market—choosing a genre solely based on its commercial success—can work, but writing something you genuinely love will always lead to more fulfilling storytelling. Passion often translates into better writing, which resonates with readers.

Common Concerns Writers Have About Genre

Concern: I don’t know what genre my story fits into.

Solution: That's okay! Many stories blend elements from multiple genres. Instead of worrying about perfect classification, focus on your main themes and story beats. If needed, you can market your book with two genres (e.g., fantasy romance, sci-fi thriller).

Concern: My story doesn’t follow all the “rules” of a genre.

Solution: That's also okay! Genres evolve over time, and subverting expectations can make your story more interesting. Understanding the “rules” allows you to break them intentionally.

Concern: What if my genre isn’t popular right now?

Solution: Trends shift constantly. A genre that’s less popular today may explode in popularity next year. If you love the genre, write it anyway—there will always be an audience.

Concern: What if I want to write in multiple genres?

Solution: Many writers do! You can establish yourself in one genre first and then branch out, or you can create different pen names for different audiences. Writing cross-genre stories is also an option.

Concern: Do I have to read every book in my genre before I write in it?

Solution: No, but reading widely in your chosen genre helps. It gives you a sense of what’s been done, what readers enjoy, and how you can innovate within the genre.

Q: Do I have to stick to just one genre?

A: Not at all! Many of today’s bestsellers blend genres.

Q: What if I love multiple genres and can’t choose?

A: Try writing short stories in each genre to find what excites you most.

Q: Is literary fiction superior to genre fiction?

A: No! Every genre has artistic merit. What matters is how well a story is told.

Personal Reflection: My Favorite Genres & Story Types

I've always been drawn to fantasy because of its limitless possibilities, but I also love weaving in mystery elements to keep readers guessing. The thrill of blending genres is where I feel most at home in storytelling. Sometimes I write stories that defy strict classification, embracing elements of fantasy, horror, and adventure all at once. The genres I love most reflect my deep curiosity about the unknown and my love for exploring human nature through imaginative storytelling. (What about you? What genres call to you the most?)

Bonus Tip: If you’re feeling stuck, try combining a random genre and story archetype. (Example: A “Voyage & Return” sci-fi mystery.)

Concluding Thoughts: Embrace Experimentation

Genres and story structures aren’t rules or restrictions—they’re tools. They provide a foundation, but the true magic of storytelling lies in how you shape them into something uniquely yours. Don’t be afraid to experiment. Blend genres, break conventions, and push beyond expectations. The stories that stand out are the ones only you can tell.

Challenge:

Write a short scene (300-500 words) in a genre you’ve never explored before. See what new creative doors it opens!

Next Steps:

Continue experimenting with different genres and archetypes to refine your storytelling voice. Pay attention to the structures and reader expectations within your chosen genre—then decide how to honor, twist, or completely subvert them.

In the next lesson, we’ll explore Internal vs. External Conflict—the backbone of every great story.

Carpe scripturam!

—Bair✍︎

🔜 Next Up: Lesson III – Internal vs. External Conflict

---

Want to stay up to-date on get exclusive updates and insights on future projects, book launches, writer and reader resources, FREE literature, writing freebies, and a more?

Sign up for my Newsletter!

Find more helpful writing tips on the rest of my blog.

Struggling to get your word count in? Check out my writing podcast!

Need a new notebook? Check out my hand-bound books!

Support the blog on Ko-fi!

INSTAGRAM | LINKEDIN | PINTEREST

---

Check out My Writer & Reader Merch Store

---

Like this post?

Share the link on your social media or

pin the image below to your Pinterest board!